Anonymous asked: What are your thoughts on issue-by-issue reviews of comics? Do these reviews have any discernible impact on an sales (i.e., do poor reviews translate into poor sales)? Should such reviews be done of trades instead so that a whole story arc is covered? Seems to me that most of the reviewers are not very insightful anyway. E.g., Newsarama's reviews of Silver Surfer have been consistently tepid even though it's a fantastic book. Reviewer's beef with the first issue was with the coloring!

brevoortformspring:

From what I can see, most reviews have no great impact on the sales of a given title by themselves. In aggregate, it’s possible to see an effect, but only in a “Rotten Tomatoes” situation where every review is similarly damning or similarly laudatory.

I’ve lamented a number of times about how I wish that there was a better standard of review available somewhere. Most of the reviews that I read aren’t what would typically be considered reviews at all—they’re more like blog postings. Not a lot of genuine critical faculties or technical knowledge or analytical thinking is applied to most reviews, it seems. They all come down much more simply to whether the reviewer liked the book or not on the most surface level.

There’s nothing wrong with any reader expressing their opinion, but I’d love to see reviews that set a higher standard. In those cases, when a reviewer’s word comes to mean something, comes to stand for something, then the reviews can have a chance to affect their readers more readily and to affect sales. You can see this with certain storied reviewers and critics of film and prose and television. And I’d love to see the same for graphic fiction.

1. awildhope liked this
2. janapursel liked this
3. mattfromitaly liked this
4. solitairerose reblogged this from brevoortformspring
5. solitairerose liked this
6. fierykillrock liked this
7. allikm liked this
8. stan-stash reblogged this from brianmichaelbendis
9. revzj liked this
10. morethansky liked this
11. kingsofsleep liked this
12. sequentialsmart reblogged this from brevoortformspring
13. sequentialsmart liked this
14. rodreilly liked this
15. daymareprime reblogged this from brianmichaelbendis
16. horsefaced liked this
17. hec-thor reblogged this from brevoortformspring
18. hec-thor liked this
19. marcofari1 liked this
20. mooserecluse reblogged this from brianmichaelbendis
21. skelldude liked this
22. upstart-crow liked this
23. windcaster864 liked this
24. diaryofataxidriver liked this
25. dwarfwheat liked this
26. 01101010j liked this
27. hikatebishop liked this
28. alexmarley5 liked this
29. enllo liked this
30. rhen-maverwyn liked this
31. malcolmloo liked this
32. raisinslut-blog liked this
33. gloriousdelibird liked this
34. gloriousdelibird reblogged this from brianmichaelbendis
35. doctorpuppy reblogged this from brianmichaelbendis
36. doctorpuppy liked this
37. anonvoice liked this
38. gadz00kins liked this
39. thekelvincelis liked this
40. steamplayny liked this
41. skipperwing liked this
42. brevoortformspring posted this
43. Show more notesLoading...